★ 4.7 Google rating · Serving Greater Vancouver since 1999
ServicesBrandsRebates ReviewsAboutContact 📞 Call (604) 473-9690

Comparing Quotes That Are Not for the Same Thing

Furnace

Comparing Quotes That Are Not for the Same Thing
Home › Comparing Quotes That Are Not for the Same Thing

Comparing Quotes That Are Not for the Same Thing

Key takeaways

  • Most of the gap between two furnace quotes is scope, not margin. Write both scopes down side by side before you look at either total.
  • The items that usually go missing are venting, gas line sizing, condensate routing, electrical, permits, disposal and code-required upgrades.
  • A complete quote names the equipment, the work, who pulls the permit, what is warranted by the manufacturer versus by the installer, and what happens if something hidden is found.
  • A gas furnace replacement and a dual fuel proposal are not the same product, so their totals were never comparable in the first place.
  • In BC, gas work and most electrical work must be done by licensed trades. You can verify a contractor’s licence yourself before you sign anything.
  • Ask every question in front of the person who wrote the quote. A good contractor is relieved to be asked, not annoyed.

If two furnace quotes for the same house come back thousands of dollars apart, the usual reason is that they are not quotes for the same job. One may include a new vent, a resized gas line, a condensate pump and a permit while the other assumes everything already in the basement gets reused. Before you can compare the numbers, you have to normalise the scope: list what each proposal actually includes, fill in the blanks by asking, and only then put the totals beside each other. This page gives you a checklist you can hold in your hand while someone is standing in your mechanical room, and it tells you what a complete, honest furnace proposal looks like so you can stop feeling cornered by a decision you are allowed to take your time on.

Why do two furnace quotes for the same house come out so far apart?

A furnace replacement is not a product purchase with an installation attached. It is a small mechanical renovation that happens to include a piece of equipment. The equipment is the part everyone talks about, and it is often the part that varies least between proposals. The work around it is where the money goes and where the proposals diverge.

Two contractors can look at the same basement and reach genuinely different conclusions. One may judge the existing vent acceptable for the appliance being installed; another may decide the vent has to change because the new appliance vents differently. One may reuse the existing gas line; another may measure the run, count the other appliances on it, and conclude it needs resizing. One may plan to slope a condensate line to an existing drain; another may see no fall available and price a condensate pump. None of that is trickery. It is judgement, and judgement is exactly what you are hiring.

The problem is that a one-page quote hides the judgement. You are handed a number and an equipment name and asked to compare it to another number and another equipment name, when the real difference sits in six or seven line items that neither page mentions. So the task is not to guess who is overcharging. The task is to make both scopes visible, then decide which scope you actually want done in your house.

What has to appear on a furnace quote before you can compare it to anything?

A quote you can compare is specific enough that a different contractor could read it and know exactly what was promised. If a line is vague, it is not a line you can price against, and vagueness is where change orders are born.

Use this as your completeness test. Anything missing is a question, not an accusation. Ask it out loud and write the answer in the margin.

  • The exact equipment: manufacturer, series or model designation, and the capacity the contractor sized it at. Ask what that sizing was based on, not just what is there now.
  • Venting: whether the existing vent is reused, relined, replaced or newly routed, and where it terminates.
  • Gas: whether the existing gas line is reused or resized, and whether any other appliances share that run.
  • Condensate: where the condensate goes, whether it drains by gravity or needs a pump, and whether a neutraliser is included.
  • Electrical: whether existing circuits and disconnects are reused, and whether any electrical work by a licensed electrician is included or excluded.
  • Controls: which thermostat is included, whether it is a straight swap, and whether new wiring is needed.
  • Ductwork: whether the plenum, transitions and returns are modified, and whether filtration housing changes.
  • Permit: who applies, who arranges the inspection, and confirmation that the permit is in the contractor’s licensed name.
  • Removal and disposal of the old appliance and any debris.
  • Warranty: what the manufacturer covers on parts, and separately what the contractor covers on their own labour. These are two different promises and should be written as two different lines.
  • Exclusions and unknowns: what the contractor has explicitly not priced, and how a hidden condition would be handled if one is found behind a wall or above a ceiling.
  • Payment terms and the schedule of work, written down rather than agreed to verbally.

How do I normalise two proposals so the comparison is real?

Normalising means forcing both quotes onto the same scope so the totals finally describe the same thing. It takes about twenty minutes at a kitchen table and it is the single highest-value thing you can do before you spend real money.

Work in this order. Do not skip to the totals, because the totals are the least informative part of either page until the rest is filled in.

  • Draw two columns on a sheet of paper and write the twelve items from the completeness list down the left side as rows.
  • Fill in what each quote says. Leave a blank where the quote is silent. Blanks are the whole point of the exercise.
  • Phone or email each contractor and ask them to fill their own blanks in writing. A short reply by email is enough; you want it on record, not because you expect a dispute but because memory is unreliable weeks later.
  • Where the two scopes genuinely differ, ask each contractor why they made their call. Vent, gas sizing and condensate are the three that most often explain a large gap.
  • Decide which scope you want. This is your decision, not theirs. If the more thorough scope is the right one, ask the other contractor to requote to match it rather than assuming they cannot.
  • Only now compare totals, and compare them per scope, not per page.
  • Check that both totals state whether GST is included, since a quoted number with and without tax reads very differently.
  • Confirm both contractors are licensed for gas work in BC and ask for the licence number. Ours are LGA0090068 and CGA0028029, and you are entitled to ask anyone for theirs.

What line items go missing from a thin quote?

The table below is the short version of the same idea: the item, why it exists, and what it usually means when a proposal does not mention it. Use it as a prompt sheet rather than as a verdict on anybody.

Line itemWhy it existsWhat silence usually means
VentingA high-efficiency furnace vents differently than an older one and the existing chimney or vent may not suit itThe vent is assumed reusable, or the change is priced later as an extra
Gas line sizingTotal appliance demand and the length of the run determine whether the existing pipe is adequateThe line is assumed adequate without measuring the run or counting other appliances
Condensate routingHigh-efficiency gas appliances produce acidic condensate that must drain or be pumpedA gravity drain is assumed, and a pump becomes an on-the-day surprise
ElectricalCircuit capacity, disconnects and controls wiring may need licensed electrical workExisting wiring is assumed adequate and reused as is
Ductwork and plenumNew equipment rarely matches the old cabinet footprint, and returns are often undersizedTransitions are assumed to fit, or sheet metal work is quoted later
Permit and inspectionGas appliance work in BC is permitted and inspected workThe permit is either not being pulled or is not included in the price
DisposalThe old appliance and packaging have to leave the propertyRemoval is assumed but not promised, which is fine until it is not
Code-required upgradesOlder installations sometimes need corrections that are unrelated to the new applianceCorrections are deferred, unpriced, or invisible until an inspector sees them
Labour warrantyManufacturer parts coverage does not cover the installer’s own workmanshipThere is only a parts warranty and no written labour commitment

What does a furnace replacement cost in ballpark terms, and what moves the number?

For a typical Metro Vancouver home, a high-efficiency gas furnace replacement lands in a ballpark range of about $5,000 to $9,000 installed, before GST, with genuinely complex jobs sitting higher. Those are ballpark figures for orientation only. They are not a quote, and an accurate price needs a site visit, because the variables below are things nobody can see from a phone call.

If the job also needs a new or resized gas line for the appliance, a short and accessible run is commonly in the ballpark of $500 to $1,500, while a long or difficult run through finished space is more often $1,500 to $3,000 and up. Adding a heat pump alongside a gas furnace as a dual fuel system is a different project altogether and is commonly a ballpark $10,000 to $18,000, with an electrical panel upgrade extra when one is required. Again, ranges, not quotes.

Notice how wide those ranges are. That width is honest. A quote that lands anywhere inside a range is not automatically fair and one that lands outside it is not automatically wrong. What matters far more than the position inside the range is which of the following the price includes.

  • Venting changes, including relining, rerouting or creating a new sidewall termination.
  • Gas line sizing and length, and whether other appliances share the run.
  • Condensate routing, including whether a pump and neutraliser are needed.
  • Electrical work, including circuits, disconnects and controls wiring by a licensed electrician where required.
  • Permits, which are set by each municipality or Technical Safety BC and vary by jurisdiction.
  • Access, which is a real cost in tight crawl spaces, narrow stairwells, lane-access homes and older attics.
  • Sheet metal work where the new cabinet does not match the old footprint, or where returns are undersized.
  • Disposal of the old appliance and any asbestos-era materials that must be handled by specialists.
  • Code-required corrections uncovered during the work, which is exactly why you want a written process for hidden conditions.
  • Rebate paperwork, financing and service-call policies, which you should evaluate qualitatively by reading the terms rather than by attaching a number to them at quoting stage.

How do I compare a gas furnace quote against a dual fuel proposal?

You do not, at least not directly. A gas furnace replacement and a dual fuel system are different products that solve overlapping but different problems, and putting their totals side by side tells you almost nothing. A dual fuel system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace kept as backup, so it adds outdoor equipment, refrigerant lines, a condensate path outdoors, controls that decide which heat source runs, and usually electrical work. It also adds cooling in summer, which a furnace alone does not provide.

The honest comparison is a decision about what you want the system to do, made before you compare prices. If you want cooling and lower operating cost through our long mild shoulder seasons, with gas heat available for cold snaps, dual fuel is the conversation. If you want to replace a failed furnace and nothing more, that is a complete and reasonable choice on its own.

When you do compare two dual fuel proposals against each other, normalise them the same way you normalised the furnace quotes, and add the dual-fuel-specific items: the changeover control strategy, where the outdoor unit sits and how it is mounted, line set routing, and whether the electrical panel has capacity or needs upgrading. Refrigerant work is legally restricted to certified technicians, so it should be clearly the contractor’s responsibility on both proposals and never something described as a homeowner task.

What if one of my options is tied to a rental agreement or an existing contract?

Sometimes the appliance in your basement is not yours. If you are renting equipment, or if there is an existing agreement attached to it, that agreement governs what happens next and it is the document you should be reading, not a summary from anyone standing in your house, including us.

The practical steps are simple and entirely within your control. Find your rental agreement. Read the sections on term, end of term, and what happens if the equipment is removed or replaced. Call the number printed on your own bill and ask your provider directly what your options are and what they involve. Ask them to confirm in writing. Do not rely on a verbal characterisation of your agreement from a third party, because only you and your provider can see the actual terms.

Once you know where your agreement stands, a replacement quote becomes comparable again, because you are comparing the installed work on its own terms. Keep those two conversations separate in your head: what your agreement says is one question, and what a new installation should cost and include is another.

What is different about comparing quotes in Metro Vancouver?

Our housing stock skews older than the equipment going into it. A great deal of Burnaby, East Vancouver, New Westminster and North Surrey housing was built when appliances vented into masonry chimneys and gas lines were sized for a different set of loads. When a modern high-efficiency furnace goes into that house, the vent almost always changes and the gas line often gets a second look. That is the single most common reason two local quotes differ by thousands.

Access is the second. Lane-access homes, tight crawl spaces, converted basements with finished ceilings, and mechanical rooms reached through a laundry room all add real labour hours that a quote written from a photo will not capture.

Strata density is the third. In a townhouse or a low-rise, the installation may need strata approval, restricted work hours, elevator or parking arrangements, and coordination about shared venting or common property. Ask both contractors whether they have priced for strata coordination, because one that has and one that has not will produce very different numbers for identical equipment.

Finally, our climate is mild and wet rather than extreme. That matters when someone is arguing for oversized equipment. Bigger is not automatically better here, and a contractor who explains their sizing reasoning is giving you something more valuable than a bigger number on a nameplate. Our soft coastal water is worth knowing about too: hydronic systems here deal with sludge and corrosion rather than heavy limescale, which shapes what maintenance work is genuinely needed.

When should I call a licensed technician?

Everything on this page that involves looking, listing, reading and asking is yours to do. You can read your own quotes, photograph your mechanical room, check a licence number, read your own agreement, and ask as many questions as you like. That is the homeowner half of the job and it is genuinely powerful.

The other half is not optional. In British Columbia, gas work must be performed by a licensed gas fitter, and most electrical work must be performed by a licensed electrician. Refrigerant handling requires a certified technician. Do not open a gas connection, alter venting, or work inside a furnace cabinet yourself, and never let an unlicensed person do it in your home regardless of price.

Call a licensed technician promptly if you smell gas, if a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, if you see soot, scorching or rust at a vent connection, if the furnace is short cycling or locking out repeatedly, or if you simply want a second set of eyes on a proposal before you sign. A site visit that produces a clear written scope is worth far more than a number over the phone, and same-day attendance is sometimes possible depending on the day and the workload, though we will always tell you honestly rather than promise an arrival window we cannot keep. BC Wide is an independent TSBC-licensed contractor, not a factory-authorised dealer, and we service equipment from the major brands rather than claiming certification from any of them. If you want a scope reviewed or a quote written the way this page describes, call (604) 473-9690.

Gas & carbon-monoxide safety: Gas furnaces, boilers, water heaters and fireplaces are combustion appliances. In British Columbia, gas fitting and most electrical work are legally restricted to licensed trades, and refrigerant handling is restricted to certified technicians. If you smell gas, leave the building first and then call from outside. Install and test carbon monoxide alarms on every level of the home, including outside sleeping areas, and never disable one that is sounding. Soot, scorching, rust at a vent connection, a persistent flue odour, or headaches and nausea that improve when you leave the house all warrant shutting the appliance down and calling a licensed technician. Never alter venting, open a gas connection, or work inside an appliance cabinet yourself.

Frequently asked questions

Is the cheapest furnace quote always the wrong one?

No. A lower price sometimes reflects a genuinely simpler scope, lower overhead, or a contractor who judged that the existing vent and gas line are adequate. It only becomes a problem when the lower price is lower because work that will be needed anyway has not been included. Normalise the scopes first, then the cheaper quote either stays cheaper for a good reason or turns out to be missing something.

How do I ask about missing line items without sounding accusatory?

Ask what, not why. Saying “Can you tell me what the plan is for the vent and the condensate?” reads as interest, while “Why did you leave that out?” reads as a challenge. Most contractors are pleased to explain their reasoning because it is the part of their work that usually goes unseen. If someone becomes defensive about a plain scope question, that reaction is itself information.

Should the permit be in my name or the contractor’s?

Gas appliance work should be permitted by the licensed contractor performing it, under their own licence. Ask which authority the permit is filed with and who arranges the inspection, since permit fees and processes are set by each municipality or Technical Safety BC and vary across Metro Vancouver. Keep a copy of the permit and the inspection result with your home records.

What should a written hidden-condition clause say?

It should say what happens if something unexpected is found once walls, ceilings or cabinets are opened. A reasonable clause commits the contractor to stopping, showing you the condition, explaining the options, and getting your written approval before any additional work or cost proceeds. Verbal assurance on this point is common and is worth converting into a written line.

How many quotes should I actually get?

Two well-normalised quotes beat five thin ones. Three is a comfortable number if you have the time, because it tends to reveal whether an unusual scope item is one contractor’s judgement or something everyone sees. Beyond three you mostly add scheduling effort rather than clarity.

Can I compare a furnace-only quote to a dual fuel quote by price per year?

You can try, but treat the result as a rough sketch rather than a decision. Operating cost depends on your usage, your building envelope, the weather in a given year and energy rates that change, so any projection carries wide uncertainty. Decide first what you want the system to do, including whether you want cooling, then compare like against like within that choice.

How do I verify that a contractor is licensed before signing?

Ask for the gas contractor licence number and the installer’s certificate, then verify it with Technical Safety BC yourself rather than taking a photo of a card as proof. Confirm the business name on the quote matches the name on the licence. Ours are LGA0090068 and CGA0028029, and any reputable contractor will give you theirs without hesitation.

BC Wide Home Services — Lower Mainland home-comfort specialists since 1999

Technical Safety BC Licensed Gas Contractor (LGA0090068) · Class B Gas Licence (CGA0028029) · Red Seal technicians · Evening and weekend calls · Diagnostic service calls $189.00 · Free in-home estimates on replacements (the $189.00 is waived if you replace with us). Call 604-473-9690 or book a free replacement estimate.

4.7★181+ Google reviews
27+Years serving Greater Vancouver
20+Brands serviced
$0Free written estimates on installs

Frequently asked questions

What HVAC services does BC Wide offer in Metro Vancouver?
BC Wide installs, services and repairs boilers, furnaces, heat pumps, hot water tanks, tankless water heaters, gas fireplaces and air conditioning across Metro Vancouver. We work on residential homes, townhouses, condos with strata systems, and small commercial buildings.
How long has BC Wide been in business?
BC Wide Heating & Air Conditioning has been serving the Greater Vancouver area since 1999. Our TSBC-licensed technicians have built a reputation as some of the most experienced furnace, boiler and heat-pump specialists in the Lower Mainland.
What areas do you serve?
We cover all of Metro Vancouver: Vancouver, Burnaby, Richmond, Surrey, Coquitlam, North Vancouver, West Vancouver, New Westminster, Delta, Langley, Port Moody, Port Coquitlam, White Rock, Pitt Meadows, and Maple Ridge.
Are BC Wide technicians licensed and insured?
Yes. BC Wide holds a TSBC gas-fitting licence, our technicians are Red Seal certified for HVAC and gas, and we carry full liability insurance and WorkSafeBC coverage.
How can I book a service call?
Call (604) 473-9690, email info@bcwide.ca, or use the booking form on bcwide.ca. Most calls are answered the same business day and we offer next-day appointments for non-emergency work.
Do you offer free estimates?
Yes. Free in-home estimates are provided for boiler, furnace, heat pump and water-heater replacements. Diagnostic visits for repairs carry a flat service fee that is credited toward the repair if you proceed.
What brands do you service?
We service all major brands including Viessmann, Navien, IBC, Rinnai, Rheem, Bradford White, Weil-McLain, Laars, Baxi, NTI, Lennox, Carrier, Bryant, Goodman, Trane, York, Daikin, Mitsubishi Electric, AO Smith, Bosch, Noritz, Giant, GSW, John Wood, and Valor.
Do you offer government rebates for heat pumps?
Yes. We are a registered contractor for BC Hydro, FortisBC and federal Greener Homes rebates. A high-efficiency heat pump installation can qualify for up to $11,000 in combined rebates depending on your home and income.
How quickly can you replace a broken hot water tank?
Standard 40 or 50-gallon gas or electric tanks are typically replaced same-day or next-day from stock. Tankless water heaters and larger commercial units usually take 1–3 business days depending on parts availability.
Why should I choose BC Wide over other HVAC companies?
BC Wide Heating & Air Conditioning has been operating in Greater Vancouver since 1999 as a TSBC-licensed (LGA90068) HVAC and gas contractor. We specialise in furnaces, boilers, heat pumps and water heaters across every major brand, we give honest options instead of upselling, and our work is performed by experienced, certified staff — not subcontractors.

What Greater Vancouver homeowners say about BC Wide

Verified Google reviews — 4.7 average across 181+ ratings
★★★★★
"Alan and Mo were amazing today. They seamlessly replaced our furnace and tankless hot water tank in record time."
Mebz Esmail
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"Alan and his colleague are very friendly and professional. They installed everything and left it clean."
Laura E. Martínez Urrutia
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"I have been using BC Wide HVAC Services for over five years for my annual maintenance."
Thor Campbell
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"Excellent service from start to finish! B.C. Wide is knowledgeable, very professional and showed up on time! I highly recommend this company."
Mark Bouffard
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"I found these guys on Google. I just moved into a place where no maintenance has been done in the last 6 years."
Thomas Lee
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"Heat pump, furnace and tankless water heater installed. Competitive price. Careful, friendly, competent, efficient installation team. Professional appearing installation. Good company, highly recommended."
Thomas T
Google review · Jul 2026

Get a Free Quote — Right From This Page

Request a Free Quote

We'll call you back fast — usually within a few hours.
✓ Thanks! We've received your request and will call you back shortly.

Get Comfortable — Talk to BC Wide Today

Free, no-obligation quotes. TSBC-licensed local technicians serving Greater Vancouver since 1999.

Licensed & Insured: Technical Safety BC Licensed Gas Contractor LGA0090068  ·  Class B Gas Licence CGA0028029  ·  Red Seal Technicians  ·  Serving Greater Vancouver since 1999
🔥 Emergency Service(604) 473-9690
📞Call NowFast Response ✉️Email UsGet A Quote