- Where a natural gas main reaches your property, natural gas is usually the simpler fuel: piped supply, no tank, no deliveries.
- Propane suits properties off the gas network, such as acreages and some rural or island lots, and heats a home just as comfortably.
- Many furnaces can run on either fuel with a manufacturer conversion kit, but only a licensed gas fitter may convert, test and label the unit.
- Propane is heavier than air and can pool in basements and crawlspaces; natural gas is lighter and rises. Detector placement differs because of this.
- Both fuels produce carbon monoxide if combustion goes wrong, so CO alarms belong on every level either way.
- A heat pump paired with a propane or natural gas furnace (dual fuel) lets the gas furnace carry the cold snaps while the heat pump handles mild coastal weather.
For most Metro Vancouver homes the answer is natural gas: if a FortisBC main runs past your lot, a natural gas furnace is simpler to live with because fuel arrives by pipe, there is no tank to site or refill, and escaping gas rises and disperses rather than settling. Propane is the right choice where there is no main, on acreages, some rural and island properties and homes at the edge of the Lower Mainland, and a properly set-up propane furnace heats a house every bit as comfortably as its natural gas twin. In fact the furnace is often the same model on both fuels, configured differently at the gas valve and burners, so the real decision is about fuel supply, storage, safety behaviour and what your property can physically accommodate. This guide, written by BC Wide Home Services, an independent TSBC-licensed gas contractor based in Burnaby since 1999 (licences LGA0090068 and CGA0028029), explains where each fuel applies, how conversion works and why it is licensed work, what owning a propane tank really involves, and how to decide between repairing, converting or replacing.
Is a propane furnace actually different from a natural gas furnace?
Mechanically, very little. The cabinet, heat exchanger, blower, inducer fan, flame sensor, igniter and control board are usually identical. What changes is how the gas is metered into the burners. Propane carries more energy per unit of volume than natural gas and is delivered to the appliance at a higher pressure, so a propane furnace uses smaller burner orifices and a gas valve regulator set for propane. Put natural gas through propane orifices and the furnace underfires; put propane through natural gas orifices and it badly overfires.
Once each fuel is matched to the right orifices and pressure, the heat delivered to your rooms, the airflow, the thermostat behaviour and the comfort are the same. Both fuels are available in mid-efficiency and high-efficiency condensing furnaces, and both can be paired with a heat pump in a dual-fuel system. So when a homeowner asks which furnace heats better, the honest answer is that the furnace does not care. The fuel decision is really about your property.
Which fuel can I actually get at my address?
In most of the urban Lower Mainland, including Burnaby, Vancouver, New Westminster, Coquitlam, Richmond, Surrey and the North Shore, natural gas from the FortisBC network is available on the street, and many homes here already have a meter even if the current heating is something else. If you are unsure, the utility can confirm whether a main runs past your lot and whether a service line can be brought to the house. That call should come before any equipment decision.
Propane becomes the practical fuel when there is no main within reach. Typical examples are rural acreages in the outer parts of Langley Township and Maple Ridge, hillside or waterfront lots where the network was never extended, some island properties, cabins and outbuildings, and older farm homes. Whether the utility will extend a main to a property is its decision, not the contractor’s, and it depends on distance and demand along the route.
Strata properties are a special case. Townhouse and apartment stratas in Metro Vancouver are overwhelmingly on natural gas, and a strata council would rarely permit a private propane tank on common property. If you live in a strata, check your bylaws before planning any fuel change.
How do propane and natural gas compare side by side?
The table below compares the two fuels on the factors that actually decide the choice for a Lower Mainland home. Neither column wins every row, which is why the answer depends on your address.
| Factor | Natural gas furnace | Propane furnace |
|---|---|---|
| Where it applies | Homes on the FortisBC network, which covers most of urban Metro Vancouver | Properties with no gas main: acreages, some rural and island lots, outbuildings |
| Fuel supply | Piped continuously; no ordering or monitoring | Delivered by truck to an on-site tank; you or your supplier monitor the level |
| On-site storage | None beyond the meter | A tank, above ground or buried, sited to code and supplier rules |
| Behaviour if it leaks | Lighter than air; tends to rise and disperse | Heavier than air; can pool in basements, crawlspaces and low spots |
| Gas detector placement | Mounted high, per the detector maker | Mounted low, near the floor, per the detector maker |
| Comfort and heat output | Same as propane when correctly set up | Same as natural gas when correctly set up |
| Equipment choice | Full range of mid-efficiency and condensing models | Most models offer a propane version or a conversion kit |
| Main supply risk | Utility outage, rare | Running the tank dry, delivery delays in snow |
| Carbon monoxide risk | Present if combustion or venting fails | Present if combustion or venting fails |
Can a furnace be converted from propane to natural gas, or the other way?
Often, yes, but only when the manufacturer lists a conversion kit for that exact model, and only by a licensed gas fitter. A kit typically contains replacement burner orifices, a regulator spring or a different gas valve, and labels identifying the new fuel. Some models also need other adjustments listed in the kit instructions. If a kit is not listed for your furnace, it cannot legally be converted and the answer becomes replacement.
A proper conversion is more than swapping parts. The fitter confirms the kit matches the model, installs it, sets the manifold pressure with a manometer, checks the firing rate against the rating plate, watches the flame pattern, performs a combustion test for carbon monoxide, checks the venting, and fixes the conversion label to the unit. The work is done under a TSBC gas permit. A furnace that is overfired can crack its heat exchanger, soot up and produce carbon monoxide; one that is underfired can form damaging condensation and ignite roughly.
Remember that the furnace is rarely the only gas appliance. When a property moves from propane to natural gas, the water heater, fireplace, range and any other gas appliance need converting or replacing too, and the tank has to be taken out of service with the supplier. Homeowners should never attempt any part of a conversion: removing orifices or adjusting a gas valve is gas work, and in BC gas work is restricted to licensed trades.
What does living with a propane tank really involve?
The fuel is the easy part. The tank and the delivery routine are what a new propane owner has to plan around.
- Ownership: tanks are either owned by the homeowner or leased from a propane supplier. A leased tank usually ties you to that supplier for fills, so read the agreement before signing.
- Siting: the tank must sit at code-required distances from building openings, property lines and ignition sources. Your installer and supplier set this; do not move or relocate a tank yourself.
- Delivery access: the truck needs a clear route and hose reach. Steep gravel driveways, locked gates and heavy snow on rural roads are the usual reasons a delivery is missed.
- Monitoring: check the gauge regularly, or ask your supplier about automatic delivery or remote monitoring. Order before the tank gets low, especially ahead of a forecast cold snap.
- Running dry: letting a tank empty is more than an inconvenience. Air and moisture can enter the system, and a qualified person typically has to leak-check the system before appliances are relit.
- Regulators and lines: the tank regulators and the piping to the house are part of the gas system and must be installed and serviced by licensed people.
Is propane more dangerous than natural gas?
Neither fuel is dangerous when the system is installed, vented and maintained properly, but they behave differently when something goes wrong. Natural gas is lighter than air, so a small leak tends to rise and dilute. Propane is heavier than air, so escaping propane can settle in basements, crawlspaces, sump pits and window wells. Many homes here have full or partial basements with the furnace downstairs, which makes that difference practical rather than theoretical.
Both fuels carry an added odourant that smells like rotten eggs. With propane, the odour can occasionally fade in a new tank or in piping, which is one reason a propane gas detector, mounted low according to its maker’s instructions, is worth having near the furnace. Carbon monoxide is a separate hazard: it comes from incomplete combustion or a blocked vent, not from the fuel itself, and it is equally possible with either gas. CO alarms belong on every level of the home and near sleeping areas regardless of fuel.
What should rural and edge-of-region homeowners in the Lower Mainland weigh?
Our mild, wet coastal climate shapes this decision more than people expect. Heating demand here is long and gentle, with months of cool, damp shoulder-season weather and only occasional hard cold snaps. That pattern suits a dual-fuel system well: a heat pump handles the mild months, and a propane or natural gas furnace takes over on the coldest nights. On a propane property, letting the heat pump carry the mild weather means fewer tank deliveries and less dependence on trucks reaching you in bad weather.
Rural properties also bring practical issues. Power outages are more common on long rural feeders, and a gas furnace of either fuel needs electricity for its igniter, inducer and blower, so it will not run without power or a properly installed backup source. Older farmhouses and acreage homes often have undersized or patched ductwork and aging chimneys or vents, which matter as much as the fuel choice. Outbuildings such as shops and studios are frequently fed from the same tank, which affects how quickly you use fuel. And if there is any chance a gas main will reach your road within the life of the new furnace, choose a model with a listed conversion kit so it can switch fuels later without replacement.
Should I repair, convert or replace my furnace?
Several things decide it. A furnace near the end of its service life, one with a cracked or rusted heat exchanger, or one whose parts are no longer available usually points to replacement. An older furnace may have no listed conversion kit at all, which settles the question if you are switching fuels. A mid-life furnace in good condition with a listed kit is usually worth converting. Venting, duct condition and the needs of your other gas appliances all feed into the answer too.
Cost enters the picture as well. A heat exchanger or control board is one of the more expensive repairs on a gas furnace, and a fuel switch that also involves a new service line, appliance conversions and tank removal is a bigger project than the furnace alone. We do not quote prices in articles because every property is different. Ask for a written quote that separates the furnace work from the fuel-supply work, so you can see exactly what you are paying for before any work begins.
When should I call a licensed gas technician?
Homeowners can safely change the furnace filter, keep the area around the furnace clear, keep snow and debris away from outdoor vent terminations and the tank, watch the propane gauge, and test their CO alarms. Everything that involves the gas valve, burners, orifices, venting, piping, regulators or wiring inside the furnace belongs to a licensed technician. Call one for any of the following.
- Any gas smell inside or outside the house (leave first, then call from outside).
- A CO alarm sounding, or headaches and nausea that ease when you leave the house.
- Converting a furnace or any other appliance from one fuel to the other.
- Bringing a furnace back on after a propane tank has run dry.
- Yellow, lazy or lifting burner flames, soot around the furnace, or scorch marks.
- Planning a fuel switch because a gas main has reached your street.
- Adding a heat pump to create a dual-fuel system with your existing furnace.
- Annual servicing, which includes a combustion check and a look at the venting.
Frequently asked questions
Is propane or natural gas better for a furnace in Metro Vancouver?
If a natural gas main reaches your property, natural gas is usually the simpler choice because supply is continuous and there is no tank to manage. If there is no main, propane is the practical option and heats just as well. The furnace itself performs the same on either fuel when it is correctly set up.
Can I convert my propane furnace to natural gas myself?
No. Conversion means changing orifices and gas valve settings, then testing pressure and combustion, and in BC that is gas work restricted to licensed gas fitters under permit. A wrong conversion can overfire the furnace, crack the heat exchanger and produce carbon monoxide.
Does every furnace have a propane conversion kit?
No. Only models for which the manufacturer lists a conversion kit can be converted, and the kit must match that exact model. If no kit is listed, the furnace cannot legally be converted and replacement is the route.
Where should a gas detector go for propane versus natural gas?
Because propane is heavier than air, propane detectors are usually mounted low, near the floor. Natural gas is lighter than air, so its detectors are usually mounted high. Always follow the detector maker’s instructions, and remember that gas detectors do not replace CO alarms.
What happens if my propane tank runs out?
The furnace and other propane appliances stop, and air and moisture can enter the system. A qualified person typically needs to leak-check the system before anything is relit, so do not try to restart appliances yourself. Monitoring the gauge or arranging automatic delivery prevents most run-outs.
Can a propane furnace be part of a dual-fuel heat pump system?
Yes. A heat pump can be paired with a propane furnace just as it can with a natural gas furnace. The heat pump handles our long mild shoulder seasons, and the furnace carries the cold snaps, which on a propane property also means fewer tank deliveries.
A gas main is coming to my street. Should I switch from propane?
Often it makes sense, but it depends on the age of your furnace and other appliances and whether they have listed conversion kits. The switch also involves a utility service line and taking the tank out of service. Ask for a written quote that covers every appliance before you decide.
BC Wide Home Services — Lower Mainland home-comfort specialists since 1999
Technical Safety BC Licensed Gas Contractor (LGA0090068) · Class B Gas Licence (CGA0028029) · Red Seal technicians · Evening and weekend calls · Diagnostic service calls $189.00 · Free in-home estimates on replacements (the $189.00 is waived if you replace with us). Call 604-473-9690 or book a free replacement estimate.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a furnace be serviced?
How long does a furnace last in Vancouver's climate?
Why is my furnace blowing cold air?
How much does a new furnace cost in Vancouver?
What is the most reliable furnace brand?
What HVAC services does BC Wide offer in Metro Vancouver?
How long has BC Wide been in business?
What areas do you serve?
What Greater Vancouver homeowners say about BC Wide
Get a Free Quote — Right From This Page
Request a Free Quote
Get Comfortable — Talk to BC Wide Today
Free, no-obligation quotes. TSBC-licensed local technicians serving Greater Vancouver since 1999.


