★ 4.7 Google rating · Serving Greater Vancouver since 1999
ServicesBrandsRebates ReviewsAboutContact 📞 Call (604) 473-9690

What Drives the Running Cost of a Tankless Water Heater

Water Heaters

What Drives the Running Cost of a Tankless Water Heater
Home › What Drives the Running Cost of a Tankless Water Heater

What Drives the Running Cost of a Tankless Water Heater

Key takeaways

  • A tankless water heater only burns gas while water is flowing, so the single largest driver of its running cost is the volume of hot water the household draws, followed by how cold the incoming city water is that month.
  • Recirculation is the most common hidden cost on a tankless system: a pump left on a continuous schedule makes the heater fire when nobody is using hot water.
  • Setpoint matters, but modestly and with limits, and there are safety and scald reasons not to chase the lowest possible number.
  • Metro Vancouver water is soft, so descaling is about heat-driven mineral deposits and debris rather than hard-water limescale, and a clogged inlet screen is often the real culprit behind poor performance.
  • A gas bill that jumps with no change in habits or weather can point at a combustion, venting or control fault and deserves a look from a licensed technician.
  • Compare one billing period against the same period a year earlier using the energy units printed on the bill, not the total amount charged.

The running cost of a gas tankless water heater is driven by four things, in this order: how much hot water the household actually draws, how cold the incoming water is when it enters the unit, how the hot water is distributed and whether it is being recirculated, and the condition of the appliance itself. Everything else, including the setpoint, the brand, and the age of the unit, moves the number far less than homeowners expect. A tankless unit fires only while water is flowing, so it does not have the standby losses a tank has, and that changes which levers are worth pulling. If your bill has jumped and nothing about your household changed, the most likely explanations in a Metro Vancouver home are a colder billing period with colder incoming water, a recirculation pump or timer that is running more than you think, a plumbing leak or a dripping hot tap that keeps the heater cycling, or a maintenance or combustion problem. This article explains each driver, ranks them, and tells you which ones are worth spending money to fix.

What actually determines what a tankless water heater costs to run?

A tankless water heater is a flow-triggered appliance. A flow sensor detects water moving, the control fires the burner, and the unit modulates its firing rate to hold the outlet at the setpoint. When the tap closes, the burner stops. That means the operating cost is close to a direct function of how many litres of hot water passed through it and how far each litre had to be raised in temperature.

The temperature rise is the part homeowners forget. The energy required is the difference between the incoming water temperature and the setpoint, multiplied by the volume drawn. In the Lower Mainland the incoming supply is noticeably colder in winter than in late summer, so the same shower costs more energy in February than it does in August even though your behaviour never changed. That single fact explains a large share of the seasonal swing people attribute to the appliance.

The table below ranks the drivers by how much they genuinely move a residential bill here, and flags whether it is worth spending money to change them.

DriverHow much it moves the billWorth spending money on?
Volume of hot water drawn (showers, laundry, dishes)Largest single factor by a wide marginYes, through low-flow showerheads and shorter draws, which are inexpensive
Incoming water temperature (seasonal)Large, and entirely outside your controlNo, this is weather, not a fault
Recirculation running when nobody needs hot waterLarge where it applies, and often invisible to the ownerYes, a demand or occupancy control usually pays for itself in comfort and energy both
Leaks and dripping hot fixturesCan be large and is frequently missedYes, always fix
Distribution losses in long, uninsulated pipe runsModerate, worse in older houses and large homesUsually yes where the pipe is accessible
SetpointModerate but bounded, with safety limitsFree to adjust, but do not chase extremes
Maintenance condition, including inlet screen and heat exchangerModerate, and it degrades quietly over yearsYes, routine service is inexpensive relative to the fault it prevents
Combustion or venting faultCan be sudden and significant, and is a safety issue firstYes, immediately, and only by a licensed technician
Brand or model choice on an already-installed unitSmall once the unit is in place and correctly sizedNo, do not replace a healthy unit to chase operating cost

Why is my gas bill higher this month when nothing changed?

Start with the bill itself before you suspect the appliance. Natural gas consumption in British Columbia is billed in energy units, not in appliance runtime, and the billing period is not always the same length. A period that covers a few more days than the previous one will read higher for reasons that have nothing to do with your water heater. Read the consumption figure and the number of days in the period, and divide, so you are comparing a daily average rather than two totals of different lengths.

Then compare against the same period one year earlier rather than against last month. Year-over-year comparison strips out the seasonal swing in incoming water temperature and in space heating. If you are also heating the house with gas, remember that the water heater is only one of several gas appliances on that meter, and that a cold snap will move the furnace or boiler far more than it moves the water heater. Isolating the water heater from a whole-house gas bill is difficult, which is why the year-over-year comparison is the honest method.

Once the arithmetic is fair, look at what changed in the house. A guest staying for a month, a teenager, a new washing machine cycle preference, a hot tub filled from the domestic hot water, or a return to the office after working from home all move hot water volume materially.

  • Divide the consumption on the bill by the days in the period to get a daily average before comparing anything.
  • Compare the same month one year earlier, not the month just past.
  • Remember the meter is shared by every gas appliance in the house, not just the water heater.
  • Note occupancy changes, new appliances and new habits before blaming the equipment.

How much does hot water use itself drive the running cost?

More than anything else. Showers are typically the largest single hot water draw in a residential home, followed by laundry and dishwashing. Because a tankless unit only consumes gas while water is flowing, the relationship between minutes of flow and energy consumed is close to linear, which makes this the most controllable driver you have.

The cheapest meaningful change most households can make is a lower-flow showerhead. It reduces litres per minute at the point of use, which reduces both the water drawn and the energy needed to heat it, and modern designs no longer feel starved. Shorter showers do the same thing without spending anything. Washing laundry on a cold or warm cycle rather than a hot one removes a large hot water draw entirely for most loads.

One caution specific to tankless equipment: some units have a minimum flow rate below which the burner will not fire. Fitting an extremely restrictive aerator or showerhead can push a fixture under that threshold and leave you with water that goes cold mid-shower. The minimum activation flow is a manufacturer-published figure, so verify it for your model before you buy a very low-flow fixture.

Does a recirculation system raise my running cost?

Yes, and this is the driver that most often explains a bill that seems too high for the household size. Recirculation moves hot water through the pipes so that it arrives at the tap quickly instead of after a long wait. That comfort is real, and in a large home it saves a significant amount of water. But the heat that leaves the pipes while the loop runs is energy you paid for and nobody used. If the pump runs continuously, or on a timer set far wider than the household actually needs, the heater will fire repeatedly through the day and night with no one drawing water.

There are three arrangements, and the distinction is the whole point. The first is a pump built into the tankless unit itself, controlled by the appliance. The second is an external pump on a dedicated return line, plumbed as a proper loop back to the heater, which is the cleanest arrangement and is what new construction generally gets. The third is a crossover or bypass-valve retrofit, where a thermostatic valve at the furthest fixture links the hot line to the cold line so the cold line acts as the return; this is the common retrofit in an older home that has no return line, and it works, but it can leave the cold line lukewarm for a while after the loop has run.

Whichever arrangement you have, the control strategy matters more than the hardware. A pump that runs only on demand, triggered by a button, a motion sensor or a smart schedule that learns the household pattern, gives you nearly the same comfort with a fraction of the running time. If you have recirculation and a bill you cannot explain, find out how the pump is being controlled before you look at anything else.

  • A built-in pump is controlled by the appliance and is configured in the unit’s own settings.
  • An external pump on a dedicated return line is the cleanest arrangement and the easiest to control well.
  • A crossover or bypass-valve retrofit uses the cold line as the return and suits older homes without a dedicated loop.
  • Continuous operation is the expensive setting; demand-triggered or tightly scheduled operation is the cheap one.

Where does hot water energy get lost between the heater and the tap?

Every metre of hot pipe between the appliance and the fixture holds water that cools between draws. In a home where the water heater sits in a garage or at one end of a long crawl space and the ensuite is at the far end upstairs, a substantial amount of already-heated water sits in the pipe and gives its heat to the building before anybody turns a tap. Each time you run the tap, you pay to heat that slug of water again.

Insulating accessible hot water pipe is one of the few genuinely worthwhile small measures. It does not eliminate the loss, it slows it, which means water in the pipe stays usable longer between draws and a recirculation loop, if you have one, needs to run less often. Focus on the first several metres out of the appliance and on any run through an unheated garage, crawl space or attic. Pipe that is buried in a finished wall is not worth opening up for this reason alone.

Fixture placement is the other half of the equation, and in a renovation it is worth planning around. Grouping wet rooms so the hot water runs are short is the sort of decision that pays back quietly for the life of the house, and it costs nothing to consider while the layout is still on paper.

Does turning the setpoint down actually save money?

It helps, but less than people expect and with real limits. Lowering the setpoint reduces the temperature rise the appliance has to deliver, which reduces the energy per litre. But it also means you mix in less cold water at the tap to reach a comfortable shower temperature, so the volume of hot water drawn goes up. The net saving is real but modest, and it shrinks the closer you get to the temperature you actually shower at.

There are two reasons not to set it too low. The first is scald safety at the other end of the scale, which is an argument for care, not for a high setpoint. The second and more important one for a water heater is that domestic hot water stored or delivered at too low a temperature creates a hospitable environment for bacteria, which is why manufacturers and codes specify minimum delivery temperatures. A tankless unit is less exposed to this than a tank because it does not store water, but the setpoint still should not be dropped arbitrarily.

The practical advice is to set the appliance where the manufacturer and your installer recommend, and to protect vulnerable occupants with thermostatic mixing at the fixture rather than by detuning the whole system. If you have children or elderly family in the house, ask your installer about mixing valves rather than dropping the appliance setpoint.

Does maintenance condition change what a tankless water heater costs to run?

Yes, gradually. Three things degrade on a tankless unit and each one shows up differently on the bill and at the tap. The inlet water filter screen collects sediment and debris from the supply and slowly restricts flow; in a home on municipal supply this is often the first thing to cause weak hot water, and it is a simple service item. The heat exchanger accumulates mineral deposits driven out of solution by heat, which insulates the exchanger surface and forces the burner to work longer to hold the setpoint. The burner and venting can develop combustion problems that reduce how much of the fuel becomes usable heat.

Descaling is genuinely worthwhile on a schedule, but do not let anyone frighten you about it here. Metro Vancouver water is soft, so what accumulates in a local tankless heat exchanger is a thin heat-driven deposit and debris rather than the thick hard-water limescale that plagues prairie and interior installations. A reasonable service interval, following what the manufacturer publishes for your model, is enough. Aggressive over-servicing is not money well spent.

A condensing tankless unit also produces acidic condensate, which drains away through a condensate line and, where required, a neutraliser. A blocked condensate drain will usually fault the appliance rather than raise the bill, but it belongs on any maintenance checklist because it is a common and easily corrected cause of a unit that stops working in the middle of winter.

  • Inlet filter screen: restricts flow and weakens hot water long before it affects anything else.
  • Heat exchanger deposits: reduce heat transfer, so the burner runs longer for the same result.
  • Burner and venting: a combustion problem is a safety issue first and a cost issue second.
  • Condensate drain and neutraliser on a condensing unit: check it as part of routine service.

What is different about running a tankless water heater in Metro Vancouver?

Three local conditions shape this. The first is our water: it is soft and it is cold. Soft water means mineral scaling is a modest maintenance item rather than a dominant one. Cold incoming water means the temperature rise the appliance must deliver in winter is larger than in most of the country’s milder-water regions, which is why a unit that felt strong in September can feel marginal in January if it was sized optimistically.

The second is our housing stock. A great deal of Burnaby, New Westminster, East Vancouver and the North Shore is older housing with gas piping sized for the original appliances and venting routes that were never planned for a high-input tankless unit. Gas-line sizing and venting are the real blockers when replacing a tank with a tankless unit here, far more often than anything to do with the water. If a previous installer undersized the gas supply, the unit may be unable to reach its full firing rate under load, and the symptom at the tap looks like poor performance rather than a piping problem.

The third is strata density. In a condominium or townhouse, the appliance may be in a closet with tight clearances, the venting may be a shared or restricted route, and any work touching common property needs strata approval and a permit path. That is worth establishing before scheduling work rather than after, and it is one of the reasons the same job takes longer in a strata than in a detached house. Our mild wet winters help in one respect: space heating dominates gas consumption here for a shorter and gentler season than in colder provinces, so the water heater is a larger share of a Lower Mainland gas bill than a homeowner moving here from elsewhere might assume.

When should you call a licensed technician?

Call when the bill moves and you cannot explain it with weather, occupancy or a leak. A sudden change in gas consumption with no change in use is one of the honest early warnings of a combustion or control fault, and it deserves a combustion check rather than a wait-and-see. Call as well if the hot water is inconsistent, if the unit is short-cycling on small draws, if you see a fault code, if the venting or the area around the appliance shows soot or staining, or if the condensate line is wet outside the pipe.

There is a clear line between what a homeowner may do and what is legally restricted in British Columbia. You may clean or replace a filter screen where the manufacturer documents it as an owner task, insulate accessible pipe, adjust a recirculation schedule through its control, read your own bill, and check fixtures for leaks. You may not perform gas work: connecting, altering or repairing gas piping, adjusting gas valves, altering venting, or servicing burners and combustion components requires a licensed gas fitter, and most electrical work requires a licensed electrician. Descaling involves isolation valves and chemistry and is usually better handled as part of a service visit than as a first do-it-yourself project.

BC Wide Home Services Ltd is an independent TSBC-licensed contractor based in Burnaby, serving Metro Vancouver since 1999 under licences LGA0090068 and CGA0028029. We are not a factory-authorised dealer for any manufacturer; we are an independent contractor that services the brands installed in local homes. If you want a written quote for service, descaling, a gas-line or venting assessment, or a recirculation control upgrade, call (604) 473-9690. We will tell you honestly whether same-day attendance is possible on the day you call, and we will not promise an arrival window we cannot keep.

Gas & carbon-monoxide safety: Gas appliances produce carbon monoxide, which has no colour and no smell. Fit working CO alarms on every level of the home, including outside sleeping areas, and test them on a schedule. If you smell gas, do not operate switches or appliances: leave the building, take everyone with you, and call from outside. Never block, extend or alter the venting on a gas tankless water heater, and never operate a unit with soot, staining or scorch marks around the vent or cabinet. An unexplained jump in gas consumption can be a symptom of a combustion problem and should be investigated rather than ignored. Gas work and most electrical work is legally restricted to licensed trades in British Columbia. To reach a licensed technician, call (604) 473-9690.

Frequently asked questions

Is a tankless water heater cheaper to run than a tank?

Generally yes on the energy side, because a tankless unit has no standby loss: it burns gas only while water is flowing, whereas a tank reheats stored water around the clock whether anyone uses it or not. How much cheaper depends entirely on the household’s hot water volume and on whether a recirculation loop is running. A low-use household with continuous recirculation can easily consume more than a high-use household without it.

Why does my bill go up in winter if I have not changed anything?

The incoming city water is colder in winter, so every litre needs a larger temperature rise to reach the same setpoint. That alone raises water heating consumption without any change in behaviour. Your gas meter also serves your space heating, which moves far more than the water heater does in a cold snap, so compare the same month one year earlier rather than comparing to last month.

Does turning down the setpoint save a meaningful amount?

It saves something, but less than you would expect, because a lower setpoint means you mix in less cold water at the tap and draw more hot water to get the same comfortable shower. There are also minimum delivery temperatures specified for hygiene reasons that you should not drop below. Protect children and elderly occupants with thermostatic mixing at the fixture rather than by detuning the whole appliance.

Should I turn off my recirculation pump to save money?

Do not simply switch it off; change how it is controlled. A pump that runs continuously or on a wide timer makes the heater fire when nobody needs hot water, while a demand-triggered or learning control gives you nearly the same comfort with a fraction of the running time. Ask your installer what control your pump has and whether it can be reconfigured or upgraded.

How often does a tankless water heater need descaling in Metro Vancouver?

Follow the interval the manufacturer publishes for your model, and verify it against the manual rather than against general advice. Our water is soft, so local units accumulate heat-driven deposits and debris rather than heavy hard-water limescale, and the service need is real but modest. A clogged inlet filter screen is a more frequent cause of weak hot water here than the heat exchanger is.

Can a fault make my tankless water heater cost more to run?

Yes. A restricted heat exchanger, a partly blocked inlet screen, an undersized or restricted gas supply, or a burner and venting problem all make the appliance work longer or less effectively for the same hot water. A combustion fault in particular is a safety concern before it is a cost concern. If consumption climbs with no change in use, have a licensed technician perform a combustion and venting check.

How do I tell whether it is the weather, the house, my habits or the equipment?

Work through them in order. Normalise the bill to a daily average and compare it to the same period a year earlier to rule out weather and billing-period length, then account for occupancy and habit changes, then check every hot fixture and the recirculation control, and only then suspect the appliance. If the first three explain nothing, book a service visit rather than guessing further.

What figures should I be looking at on the bill itself?

Look at the consumption figure in energy units and the number of days in the billing period, not the total amount charged, because rates change and a total mixes rate changes in with usage changes. Your appliance’s input rating and its minimum activation flow are on the rating plate and in the manufacturer’s documentation. Those published figures are what you should verify against for your specific model rather than relying on general numbers.

Related services & guides

BC Wide Home Services — Lower Mainland home-comfort specialists since 1999

Technical Safety BC Licensed Gas Contractor (LGA0090068) · Class B Gas Licence (CGA0028029) · Red Seal technicians · Evening and weekend calls · Diagnostic service calls $189.00 · Free in-home estimates on replacements (the $189.00 is waived if you replace with us). Call 604-473-9690 or book a free replacement estimate.

4.7★181+ Google reviews
27+Years serving Greater Vancouver
20+Brands serviced
$0Free written estimates on installs

Frequently asked questions

How long does a hot water tank last?
A standard gas or electric storage tank lasts 8–12 years. A high-quality tank with annual anode rod inspection can reach 15 years. Tankless water heaters typically last 18–22 years when descaled annually in Metro Vancouver's moderately hard water.
Should I switch to a tankless water heater?
Tankless makes sense if you have high demand (large family, multiple bathrooms running at once), want to free up floor space, or value endless hot water. Upfront cost is higher ($3,500–$6,000 installed vs $1,800–$3,200 for a tank) but operating cost is 25–40% lower for gas tankless.
My hot water tank is leaking — is it an emergency?
If the leak is from the tank body itself (not a valve or fitting), the tank is at end of life and needs replacement, usually within 24–48 hours before it floods. Shut off the water supply and gas/electric to the tank and call us.
What brands of water heaters do you install?
We install and service Bradford White, Rheem, AO Smith, John Wood, Giant, GSW for storage tanks; and Navien, Rinnai, Noritz, Bosch and Rheem for tankless units.
Can I install a water heater myself?
In BC, gas water heater installations must be performed by a TSBC-licensed gas fitter and are subject to permit and inspection. Electric tanks require a licensed electrician for the connection. BC Wide handles permits as part of every installation.
What HVAC services does BC Wide offer in Metro Vancouver?
BC Wide installs, services and repairs boilers, furnaces, heat pumps, hot water tanks, tankless water heaters, gas fireplaces and air conditioning across Metro Vancouver. We work on residential homes, townhouses, condos with strata systems, and small commercial buildings.
How long has BC Wide been in business?
BC Wide Heating & Air Conditioning has been serving the Greater Vancouver area since 1999. Our TSBC-licensed technicians have built a reputation as some of the most experienced furnace, boiler and heat-pump specialists in the Lower Mainland.
What areas do you serve?
We cover all of Metro Vancouver: Vancouver, Burnaby, Richmond, Surrey, Coquitlam, North Vancouver, West Vancouver, New Westminster, Delta, Langley, Port Moody, Port Coquitlam, White Rock, Pitt Meadows, and Maple Ridge.

What Greater Vancouver homeowners say about BC Wide

Verified Google reviews — 4.7 average across 181+ ratings
★★★★★
"Alan and Mo were amazing today. They seamlessly replaced our furnace and tankless hot water tank in record time."
Mebz Esmail
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"Alan and his colleague are very friendly and professional. They installed everything and left it clean."
Laura E. Martínez Urrutia
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"I have been using BC Wide HVAC Services for over five years for my annual maintenance."
Thor Campbell
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"Excellent service from start to finish! B.C. Wide is knowledgeable, very professional and showed up on time! I highly recommend this company."
Mark Bouffard
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"I found these guys on Google. I just moved into a place where no maintenance has been done in the last 6 years."
Thomas Lee
Google review · Aug 2026
★★★★★
"Heat pump, furnace and tankless water heater installed. Competitive price. Careful, friendly, competent, efficient installation team. Professional appearing installation. Good company, highly recommended."
Thomas T
Google review · Jul 2026

Get a Free Quote — Right From This Page

Request a Free Quote

We'll call you back fast — usually within a few hours.
✓ Thanks! We've received your request and will call you back shortly.

Get Comfortable — Talk to BC Wide Today

Free, no-obligation quotes. TSBC-licensed local technicians serving Greater Vancouver since 1999.

Licensed & Insured: Technical Safety BC Licensed Gas Contractor LGA0090068  ·  Class B Gas Licence CGA0028029  ·  Red Seal Technicians  ·  Serving Greater Vancouver since 1999
🔥 Emergency Service(604) 473-9690
📞Call NowFast Response ✉️Email UsGet A Quote