What to Ask Before Approving a Conversion
- Before approving a conversion, ask what changes outside the appliance itself: venting route and category, combustion air, gas line and meter capacity, electrical capacity, condensate drainage, and what happens to the old chimney.
- Ask for the plan in writing, including who pulls the permit, what gets inspected, and whether strata or municipal approval is needed.
- The distribution system matters as much as the appliance. Ducts or piping sized for the old equipment often need rework for the new one.
- An abandoned or now-oversized chimney is a genuine carbon monoxide hazard if another gas appliance still vents into it. Ask directly how that is being handled.
- Sometimes the honest answer is that a like-for-like replacement serves you better than a conversion, and a good contractor will say so.
- Heat pumps in our climate work best as dual fuel, paired with a gas furnace kept as backup for cold snaps.
Before you approve a conversion, ask the contractor to walk you through six things in writing: how the new appliance will vent and where that vent will terminate, whether your gas line and gas meter can carry the new load, whether your electrical panel has capacity for what is being added, where condensate will drain and whether it needs neutralising, what happens to the existing chimney and any other appliance still using it, and who pulls the permit. Those six answers tell you almost everything about whether this job is straightforward, genuinely expensive, or a bad fit for your house. A conversion is not a swap. When you change the type of appliance, you change the set of systems it has to connect to, and the cost and the risk both live in those connections rather than in the box itself.
What counts as a conversion, and why does it matter more than a replacement?
A replacement puts a newer version of the same kind of appliance in the same place, using the same vent, the same gas connection and the same distribution system. A conversion changes the type: an older mid-efficiency furnace to a condensing furnace, a boiler and tank water heater to a combi boiler, a tank water heater to a tankless unit, a furnace-only system to dual fuel with a heat pump added, or moving an appliance from one location in the house to another.
The reason this distinction matters is that a conversion breaks assumptions the original installer made. A mid-efficiency furnace vented up a masonry chimney because its exhaust was hot enough to rise. A condensing furnace does not produce that heat, so it needs plastic venting out a sidewall and a drain for the acidic water it makes. That single change cascades into venting, drainage, chimney status and sometimes the location of the equipment itself.
So the first question to ask is simply: am I being quoted a replacement or a conversion? If the answer is a conversion, every question below applies.
What are the exact questions to ask before I sign?
Ask these plainly and expect specific answers, not reassurance. A contractor who has actually looked at your house can answer all of them from the site visit.
- Where does the new vent run, where does it terminate outside, and what is the clearance to windows, doors, the gas meter, decks and the property line?
- What venting category and material does the new appliance require, and does any of the existing venting get reused?
- Is the existing gas line large enough for the new appliance, and what is the total load on the meter once everything in the house is counted?
- Does my gas meter need upsizing, and who arranges that with the utility?
- Is there enough combustion air and makeup air in the space, especially if the appliance sits in a small closet or a tight mechanical room?
- Where does condensate drain to, does it need a neutraliser, and is that drain protected from freezing?
- What is my electrical panel capacity, and does anything being added need a new circuit or a panel upgrade?
- What happens to the chimney, and is any other appliance still venting into it after this work?
- Do the existing ducts or the existing hydronic piping suit the new appliance, or do they need modification?
- Who pulls the permit, what gets inspected, and when do I see the final inspection result?
- If I am in a strata, what approval is required and who submits it?
- What is not included in this price, and what would trigger a change order once the old equipment comes out?
What knock-on work actually drives the cost of a conversion?
Homeowners tend to compare appliance to appliance and are then surprised by the spread between quotes. The spread is almost never the box. It is the work around the box, and the honest way to read a quote is to look for those items line by line.
Venting is usually the biggest single driver. A new sidewall vent may need a long horizontal run through finished ceilings, a core through a foundation wall, or a route that satisfies clearance rules on a narrow lot. Gas is the second: an older home may have a line sized for a small appliance, and increasing the load can mean new pipe from the meter, or the utility upsizing the meter itself. Electrical comes third, particularly where a conversion adds load to a panel that was full when it was built.
Then come the smaller items that add up: condensate routing and neutralisation, a chimney liner or a proper abandonment, disposal of the old equipment, sealed combustion air where the room is tight, code upgrades that get triggered when you touch the system, access difficulty in a crawlspace or a tight attic, and the permit and inspection process itself. Permit fees themselves are set by each municipality or by Technical Safety BC, so ask who handles them rather than assuming they are folded in.
What do conversions cost in Metro Vancouver?
Ballpark installed ranges in Greater Vancouver, before GST, look roughly like this: a high-efficiency gas furnace replacement typically lands in the $5,000 to $9,000 range, with complex jobs above that, while a tank-to-tankless conversion typically lands in the $4,500 to $8,000 range and up. These are ballpark figures for orientation only. They are not a quote, and an accurate price needs a site visit, because the knock-on work described above varies enormously from house to house.
For further orientation, a condensing gas boiler replacement commonly falls in the $7,000 to $15,000 ballpark and a gas combi boiler installation in the $8,000 to $14,000 ballpark and up. Adding a heat pump to an existing gas furnace to create a dual-fuel system commonly falls in the $10,000 to $18,000 ballpark, with an electrical panel upgrade extra where one is required. Running a new gas line to an appliance ranges from roughly $500 to $1,500 where the run is short and accessible, up to $1,500 to $3,000 or more where it is long or difficult.
Every one of those ranges is wide on purpose. A conversion in a 1950s house with a masonry chimney, a full panel and a finished basement ceiling is a different job from the same conversion in a 2005 house with a utility room on an exterior wall. Rebates, incentives and financing may change what you ultimately pay, but those are worth discussing qualitatively with your installer rather than folding into a headline number.
What changes when the new appliance vents differently?
Venting is where most conversion surprises live, and it is also where the safety risk sits. The table below lays out the common shifts and what each one pulls with it.
| What changes | Why it happens | What it drags in |
|---|---|---|
| Chimney to sidewall vent | Condensing appliances have cooler exhaust that will not rise up a masonry flue | Wall penetration, clearance to windows and meters, route through finished space, exterior termination |
| Metal vent to plastic vent | Condensing exhaust is wet and acidic | Correct material and slope, joint method, support, condensate drainage at the appliance |
| Atmospheric to sealed combustion | New appliance draws combustion air directly from outdoors | A second pipe or concentric vent, and a rethink of room air in a tight closet |
| Appliance leaves a shared chimney | One appliance converts, another stays behind | The flue is now oversized for what remains, which can cause poor draught and spillage |
| Appliance relocates | New unit is smaller or needs a different vent route | New gas run, new electrical, new drain, duct or piping rework at the old and new locations |
| New condensate produced | Condensing equipment makes acidic water continuously | Drain location, neutraliser, freeze protection, and a pump where gravity drainage is unavailable |
What about the ducts or the piping the old system used?
A conversion changes what the distribution system is being asked to do. Ducts sized for an older furnace that moved a lot of hot air may be undersized in static pressure terms for a modern system, and the symptom is not a dramatic failure but rooms that never balance, a noisy return, and a blower working harder than it should. If you are adding a heat pump to your furnace for dual-fuel operation, this matters more, because a heat pump moves a larger volume of cooler air for longer stretches and unforgiving ductwork shows up immediately.
On the hydronic side, older piping and older radiators were sized for higher water temperatures than a condensing boiler wants to run at. A condensing boiler only reaches its best efficiency when it gets cool water back, so a conversion that keeps high-temperature emitters and high-temperature settings can leave you paying for condensing equipment you never actually use as intended. Ask specifically what return water temperature the design assumes and whether the controls will be set up for outdoor reset.
Ask whether a proper heat loss calculation and a duct or emitter assessment are part of the quote. Sizing a conversion off the nameplate of the old appliance repeats whatever mistake was made decades ago.
When is a conversion the wrong answer?
A conversion is the wrong answer more often than the market admits, and a contractor talking you out of one is doing you a favour. If your current appliance is mid-life and working, if the venting path to a sidewall is genuinely impractical, if the gas and electrical upgrades needed swamp the value of the change, or if you plan to sell within a couple of years, a straight like-for-like replacement is frequently the better purchase.
There are also cases where the conversion is right but the timing is not. If a re-roof, a foundation repair, a panel upgrade or a strata building envelope project is already on the calendar, sequencing the heating work with it can save you opening the same walls twice.
Where a conversion genuinely earns its cost is when the existing setup forces it: a failed appliance that cannot be vented the old way any longer, a boiler and tank pair where one unit would serve better, a mechanical room you want to free up, or a household that wants cooling and is best served by adding a heat pump alongside the gas furnace. In our climate that dual-fuel pairing is the sensible shape, because the heat pump carries the mild months and the gas furnace stays in place for the cold snaps rather than being removed.
What is different about conversions in Metro Vancouver?
Our housing stock is the first factor. Large parts of Burnaby, East Vancouver, New Westminster and the North Shore are full of homes built when a masonry chimney served both the furnace and the water heater. Convert one of them and the chimney is instantly oversized for the other, which is a draught and carbon monoxide question that must be answered on paper before the work starts, not discovered afterwards.
The climate is the second. Mild, wet winters mean long shoulder seasons and relatively few deeply cold days, which is exactly the profile where dual-fuel operation makes sense and where sizing purely off the coldest hour of the year overshoots. Our water is soft, which is good news for hydronic systems in one way and bad news in another: soft water means sludge and corrosion rather than heavy limescale, so a conversion is the moment to talk about system flushing, proper filtration and air separation on a boiler job.
Third is the approvals layer. Permits are handled by your municipality, gas work is regulated through Technical Safety BC, and strata buildings add their own approval step for anything that touches a wall, a roof, a common vent or the building envelope. In a strata, get the approval process started early. It is the most common reason a scheduled conversion slips.
When should I call a licensed technician?
Gas work in British Columbia is legally restricted to licensed gas fitters, and most electrical work is restricted to licensed electricians. As a homeowner you may reasonably read your own gas bill and panel labels, look at where your existing vent terminates, note the make and model plate on your current appliance, check whether you have a working carbon monoxide alarm on every level, and ask every question on this page. Everything past that, including any connection, any venting change, any gas line work, any refrigerant work on a heat pump and any panel change, belongs to a licensed trade.
Call a licensed technician promptly if you see soot or scorching around an appliance, water staining near a vent, a pilot or burner flame that is lazy and yellow rather than crisp and blue, or a carbon monoxide alarm that sounds. Call if the appliance is short-cycling, making new noises or failing to hold temperature. And call before you commit to a conversion, because the site visit is what turns the list of questions above into real answers for your specific house.
BC Wide Home Services Ltd has been serving Metro Vancouver since 1999 as an independent TSBC-licensed contractor, licences LGA0090068 and CGA0028029. We service a wide range of equipment brands as an independent contractor rather than as a factory-authorised dealer of any one of them. Same-day attendance is sometimes possible and sometimes it is not, depending on the day and the workload, and we will tell you honestly which it is rather than promise an arrival window we cannot keep. To talk through a conversion before you approve it, call (604) 473-9690.
Frequently asked questions
What is the single most important question to ask before approving a conversion?
Ask where the new appliance will vent, where the vent will terminate outside, and what happens to the existing chimney. Venting drives the biggest share of the cost and carries the real safety consequence, because a flue left oversized for a remaining appliance can spill exhaust back into the house. If the contractor cannot describe the exact vent route from the site visit, the quote is not yet a plan.
Do I need a permit for a heating conversion in BC?
Yes, conversions involving gas appliances and venting require permitting and inspection, with gas work regulated through Technical Safety BC and building or mechanical permits handled by your municipality. Ask directly who pulls the permit, what gets inspected and when you will see the final result in writing. Permit fees are set by each municipality or by Technical Safety BC rather than by the contractor.
Will my existing ducts work with a new system?
Not automatically. Ducts sized for an older furnace can be undersized in static pressure terms for modern equipment, and the problem shows up as unbalanced rooms and a noisy, hard-working blower rather than an outright failure. This matters most when adding a heat pump for dual-fuel operation, since a heat pump moves a larger volume of cooler air for longer periods, so ask whether a duct assessment and a heat loss calculation are included.
My furnace and water heater share a chimney. What happens if I only convert one?
The chimney becomes oversized for the appliance that remains, which can weaken draught and allow combustion products to spill into the living space. The fix is usually either lining the flue to suit the remaining appliance or converting both appliances together so the chimney can be properly abandoned. Ask for this to be addressed in the written plan before any work starts, not resolved on site afterwards.
When is a like-for-like replacement better than a conversion?
A replacement usually wins when your current appliance is mid-life and reliable, when the venting path for a condensing unit is genuinely impractical in your building, when the required gas and electrical upgrades cost more than the benefit of changing type, or when you are selling soon. A conversion earns its cost when the existing setup forces the change or when you are gaining something real, such as adding cooling or freeing up a mechanical room. A contractor who tells you a conversion is not worth it is giving you useful advice.
Should I remove my gas furnace when adding a heat pump?
In Metro Vancouver the sensible arrangement is dual fuel, where the heat pump is added and the gas furnace stays in place as backup for cold snaps. That way the heat pump carries our long mild shoulder seasons and you retain proven capacity for the coldest stretches. Removing the furnace also removes your fallback, so keeping it is the more robust approach for this climate.
Why do quotes for the same conversion vary so widely?
Because the appliance is a small part of the job and the connecting work is the large part. Venting route, gas line and meter capacity, electrical capacity, condensate routing, chimney handling, duct or piping rework, access and disposal vary enormously between houses and between quotes. Read each quote for what it includes in those categories rather than comparing headline numbers, and ask what would trigger a change order once the old equipment is removed.
How long does a conversion take?
A straightforward conversion in an accessible mechanical room is often a one to two day job, while one involving new venting through finished space, a gas line upgrade, a meter change or electrical work can stretch across several days plus scheduling around the utility and the inspector. Strata approval can add weeks before work begins. Ask for the expected timeline in writing, including the inspection step, so you know when you will be without heat or hot water.
BC Wide Home Services — Lower Mainland home-comfort specialists since 1999
Technical Safety BC Licensed Gas Contractor (LGA0090068) · Class B Gas Licence (CGA0028029) · Red Seal technicians · Evening and weekend calls · Diagnostic service calls $189.00 · Free in-home estimates on replacements (the $189.00 is waived if you replace with us). Call 604-473-9690 or book a free replacement estimate.
Frequently asked questions
What HVAC services does BC Wide offer in Metro Vancouver?
How long has BC Wide been in business?
What areas do you serve?
Are BC Wide technicians licensed and insured?
How can I book a service call?
Do you offer free estimates?
What brands do you service?
Do you offer government rebates for heat pumps?
How quickly can you replace a broken hot water tank?
Why should I choose BC Wide over other HVAC companies?
What Greater Vancouver homeowners say about BC Wide
Get a Free Quote — Right From This Page
Request a Free Quote
Get Comfortable — Talk to BC Wide Today
Free, no-obligation quotes. TSBC-licensed local technicians serving Greater Vancouver since 1999.


